Sunday Morning ~ Rural Health Care Crisis––Don’t Spill the Maize

Sunday Morning ~ Rural Health Care Crisis–––Don’t Spill the Maize

Mtunkha-tunkha udatayitsa lipande. ~ Moving all the time spilled the pounded maize.

~ Chewa proverb

November 1, 2026

Hi Everyone,

I did a talk last week to the Senior College here, about the rural health care crisis and what it will mean for both the women and economies of rural Maine. I was nervous and confused about why I was so anxious. I was terribly anxious before the TED talk in 2016 (in fact, I think that was the most anxious I’ve ever been in my life) but I’m not usually nervous about public speaking. Rural health care should have been well within my comfort zone. I love educating the public about the plight of rural women and what we can do about it. So what was my problem?

I spent the week madly researching stats and getting sources for all my arguments. I had one hour for the presentation, not long for such a topic, and I fretted about how to organize the information, how to appear informed not angry (though I am angry), and leave the attendees with a sense that there are solutions to this vast problem. 

I thought and thought about why I was so anxious about this talk? In retrospect I think it was PTSD. I knew there’d be retired doctors and administrators in the audience. In my career I’d sat through countless meetings where I made the argument for more midwives in rural areas, pointed out injustice in hospital financial priorities, questioned peer review practice among doctors noting the lack of consequences for unsafe or unethical practice. I was shot down over and over again. Dismissed as angry (as if women needlessly dying shouldn’t make me angry) it was like being mocked. And I had it good! I was in a community and hospital that valued my practice. The administration knew what I brought in. I was invited to be a voting member of the medical staff, something many midwives are denied in their hospital settings. Many have to fight tooth and nail for this right. I was invited in. I’m grateful for that. But in my tenure there, I was shot down a lot, especially toward the end.

As reimbursement changed and new medical staff arrived, a new physician who did his own c-sections created a lot of friction. It became all about the money he was bringing in. Our c-section rate went from 10% to 30%. This is an outrage. This revenue and the idea that “his patients loved him” were enough to tolerate his unethical behavior. I can see the dilemma for an institution that is struggling financially, especially when the administration and hospital board are not medical people. It looks like you’ve just been handed a gift of 20% more income-producing procedures. Exploitation is an addictive drug. But there was a huge cost to this income. I quit. Another incredible doctor, who’d been arguing for justice for these women, quit. We were both assets who were not valued to the extent we should have been. It was all so short-sighted and a microcosm of what is happening now on a larger scale.

For my talk I started with a history of hospitals and how they were funded to give some context for our present crisis. Hospitals evolved over the past 400 years. Sick and dying people used to be cared for at home, including surgeries which were done on the kitchen table. Hospitals started as charitable institutions to care for the indigent, those who had no homes, and were dying of diseases prevalent in poverty stricken populations. Outcomes were poor and hospitals had bad reputations. 

The first hospital in America was started by Benjamin Franklin in 1751 in Pennsylvania. His vision was to treat medical conditions but also to provide a place for medical education as doctors then were forced to travel to Europe to learn medicine. The Pennsylvania hospital became an institution offering free care and mental health services to those who needed it. But it was Florence Nightingale, by professionalizing nursing, who transformed the hospital reputation. She taught sanitation and compassionate care and brought nursing from a disreputable profession into a noble calling for women of the time. Hospitals became a place of healing, teaching, learning, and compassion. They evolved to centers of scientific excellence.

Most of the dramatic changes in hospital care began after WWII with the Hill-Burton Act when the federal government infused money into community hospital systems to address the shortage of hospital beds in those areas. The act stipulated the hospitals would then offer free or reduced cost care to those in need. They must provide emergency care regardless of ability to pay. Then, as the National Institute for Health (NIH) grew and medical advances incorporated more technologies, care became much more expensive. When medical providers were challenged for poor outcomes with lawsuits, the malpractice industry, along with insurance for care, further inflated costs. The complexities are vast but this is a taste of what has brought us to this crisis in maternity care. It has become too expensive for community hospitals to provide. Or, so say the boards of these hospitals. Again, this is so short-sighted, lacking of creativity, and an abuse of human rights. I emphasized that when reimbursement changes, medical practice changes. The closing of maternity services is ignorant of history. Of all the changes in health care delivery, the essence of maternity care will remain. There should be an eternal way to provide this care. And there is. 

I went though the case study of the Women’s Health Center here and how we provided safe and excellent maternity care without an OB/GYN. We did this with a midwife, family practice doctor, and general surgeon. It is a model for rural health care. The only reason it can’t be immediately implemented is there are not currently enough of these professionals. I believe the solution to this is to educate those already living in these communities to provide these services. If we spent more time improving the education system, opened medical careers to those interested but less advantaged, and promoted a healthy rural economy, we could offer the needed services with fiscal responsibility.  

I was prepared to be attacked and dismissed. I was prepared to be called extreme, angry, a turn-off. I came loaded for bear and ready to support and refute. But the audience was engaged, supportive, and very interested. What I was not prepared for was the question I got on the way out. “Do you think you could call it something else besides midwifery? It has such a old fashioned meaning. Do you think that might help?” My heart sank. For the forty years I have been involved in this profession, our national organization has struggled with this. How can we educate the public to understand that we are professionals? We are not witches. We don’t live in darkness. We provide the best skilled care with advanced education. We are part of an extended team. With all the women who have used our services, benefitted from our skills, whether at home, in the hospital, or birth center, why does the population at large still not understand what we do? I believe it is because the medical system keeps it that way. Everyone in Europe understands midwifery care. But here, midwifery delivery of safe affordable maternity care and fewer complications does not bring in the big bucks. I am so sick of this crisis. 

But a crisis is an opportunity. And when this whole medical house of cards collapses, we need to be ready to rewrite the rules making midwifery mainstream, funding education, and restructuring hospitals as true non-profits funded by tax revenue with the public as shareholders. We will have a midwifery school in Maine if we keep focused on this fundamental piece of the solution. When I start to lose hope I think of this proverb and stay the course. Don’t jump around. Don’t spill the maize. 

Vote!!

Love to all,

Linda